CarWale
    AD

    Ideal Small City car - Super Value for Your Money

    8 years ago | Vishy

    User Review on Tata Nano GenX XTA

    Detail Review:
    Rating parameters
    (out of 5)

    5.0

    Exterior

    3.0

    Comfort

    3.0

    Performance

    3.0

    Fuel Economy

    5.0

    Value for Money

    PURCHASE:
    New

    DRIVING:
    Few hundred kilometers

    Exterior

    - Beats all cars in this category (<4 L) hands down - Looks are just awesome

    - A Head turner, especially the dark colors - You can notice people talking about the "practicality" of owning this small wonder

    - Classy European compact car looks with the grill & curves

    - I got a Sun Roof done from the showroom - adds to style, and allows my kid to search for the moon while I am concentrating on the road

    Interior (Features, Space & Comfort)

    - Very spacious for a car of this category

    - Rear passengers too have ample leg room

    - Hatch allows you to pack in 4 backpacks or 1 to 2 cabin bags

    - Finish is good, Tata is showing signs of "rub off" of it's global brands now

    Engine Performance, Fuel Economy and Gearbox

    - Engine is low powered (Honestly, who cares!, given the stop & go traffic in Bangalore??, I have seend people in 2.5 Ltr cars struggle to park them, take them out of the parallel park lots, while I am already 1 km away after getting out of the squeezed place)

    - I have driven it for about 600 Kms in the last 30 days - That is the love you fall into with AMT. Given it is still warly days, Fuel Efficiency is not something to comment on. Although, I get a feel that AMT will land you somewhere in the 18+ Range.

    - This car is for the practical, take it easy type fellow - not for the 4000 RPMer, who talks and breathes Bhp or Torque. Please note, that this car is an easy goer - even when you floor it, it will take its own sweet time to "calculate the down shift". So - you need to get used to it - press the pedal, half way on the speed breaker, and by the time the rear wheel is off, the car is ready to respond. A Lag of about 1.5-2 seconds for that shooting speed needed. Those used to an always on "turbo" will be left high n dry.

    - Brakes - All Drum. I feel rear discs should have been provided, given it's rear load. Brakes give you th eold "maruti 800" feeling and you are always keeping a safe distance. Something not to worry  - given that this is primarily a city car. If you want to highway throttle it, It is at your own risk.

    - Gearbox: Top gear is 5th, that engages past 65/70. For an uphill start, it is recommended to use hand brakes, since the car is on a underpowered engine.

    - Auto Creep Feature: Best part for stop n go traffic of Any Metro city. Leave the brake, and the car begins to roll - no need to alternate between accelerator & brake.

    - Enging cooling radiator comes to the front grill - Thus oveheating issues have been taken care of now.

    Ride Quality & Handling

    - Ride Quality : Smooth, well balanced, small - so - speed bumps feel a bit too short.

    - Handling: Can take a U turn whilst other car drivers are still planning their U turns :) - and off you go!

    - There is a "sport" mode, that basically does a gear shift @ about 10-15% higher RPMs, i dont use it.

    Final Words

    - Practical city car, has to be your ideal second car.

    - Not for the Highways

    - Highly recommended for those who live life "easy" - This car will give you that feel - just chill - Live and let live.

    - We compared this to Alto AMT, E2O - This one beats them all hands down especially for the price to value conscious fellow.

    - For the record, my other car is a Vista Qaudrajet. [ It is odd numbered too :) ]

    Areas of improvement  

    - Disc Brakes

    - Plastic moulds, especially door opening knobs, and dash glove box - need to be more soft, sturdy & easy to operate

    - Driver seat height adjustement, Although this is limited due to battery sitting below it.

    - Seats are a bit upright, Bucket chairs would have been good - Although for short city rides, seats are ok.

    Turning Radius, High Vantage Point, Maneuverability, Ground ClearanceSeats are rigid, Plastic moulds need more meat
    Was this review helpful?
    Like Button
    10
    DisLike Button
    1
    More User Reviews
    8 years ago | Sajith
    Was this review helpful?
    Like Button
    4
    DisLike Button
    0
    8 years ago | Vignesh
    Was this review helpful?
    Like Button
    6
    DisLike Button
    0
    8 years ago | Raj Banerjee
    Was this review helpful?
    Like Button
    7
    DisLike Button
    0
    9 years ago | Chinmay Biswas
    Was this review helpful?
    Like Button
    38
    DisLike Button
    0
    9 years ago | Ruchir Sahai Mathur
    Was this review helpful?
    Like Button
    12
    DisLike Button
    0

    Reviews you may also consider

    AD
    Write Review
    Write a detailed review of a car and you can
    scissors image
    Win Amazon Voucher worth
     ₹
    2000

    Want to read the reviews for any other car?