CarWale
    AD

    Chevrolet U-VA vs Hyundai i10 vs Maruti Suzuki Ritz

    Authors Image

    Vikrant Singh

    17,374 Views

    Overview

    Chevrolet U-VA vs Hyundai i10 vs Maruti Suzuki Ritz

    The new benchmark for small cars Every once in a while comes a car that redefines the segment. The i10 was that car. Now, can the Ritz do the same? We have the i10 and the VFM U-VA with us to find out.

    The Hyundai i10 is the benchmark small car today. It is small enough to make it a great city car, and large and supportive enough on the inside to seat four adults in comfort. It’s also peppy enough to leave a few sedans behind while returning fuel efficiency figures its brethren can’t ignore. But now, it has serious competition in the shape of the Maruti Suzuki Ritz. We have brought the two together along with the Chevy U-VA, another good valuefor- money car, to see if the i10 can retain its crown.

    Exterior & Interior

    Chevrolet U-VA Interior

    Plastics don't exude class and even the top of the line LT variant does not sport a stereo as standard. It does get power windows all round though

    Chevrolet U-VA Exterior

    U-VA has acceptable handling and steering feel

    The European influence The Ritz, which is based on the same platform as the Swift but sits on a smaller wheelbase, is the Wagon R replacement for Europe. And it shows in its styling. The chunky proportions, the large grille, the well defined shoulder lines and the flared wheel arches, all hint at the same. It’s quite pleasing on the inside too, sporting the funkiest dash design of the lot on test here. The dash mounted tacho in particular looks really cool. It does nonetheless borrow quite a few bits from its cousin, the Swift, like the multi-functional steering wheel, the stalks as well as the power window switches.

    The i10 is pretty close in design terms both inside and out. It too follows the European design language, but park it next to the Ritz and it looks a little jaded. However, the award for the oldest, least inspiring design goes to the U-VA. It is a Korean design and one that has been around for ages. Inside too, it lacks appeal and the cheap looking plastics all round don’t do it any favours. It is as well built as the Ritz though, with the i10 only inching ahead slightly.

    Comfortwise, the Ritz is easily ahead. To begin with it rides well absorbing nearly everything with aplomb, especially at slower speeds. It also has comfy frontseats, and the ones at the rear might lack decent back and side support but these support the thighs quite well indeed. The Suzuki is also the quietest of the lot on test here which further adds to the comfort factor.

    Hyundai i10 Interior

    i10 interiors are smart and well put together. The clocks are easy to read and though it gets an integrated stereo, there are no controls on the steering

    Hyundai i10 Exterior

    Good cornering behaviour, but tends to understeer

    The i10 has the worst noise suppression. But, it compensates for it by providing the best seats in the house. The front two are accommodating, supportive and with the right firmness. The rear ones hold you in place better than the Suzuki too. And, even though the Hyundai might not ride as plush as the Ritz, being a tad stiffly setup, but it still hasrespectable ride. The U-VA on the other hand has none of these attributes. The seats lack adequatesupport and the car also tends to crash into pot holes (no matterwhat speed) which leave the occupants uncomfortable.

    The space issue The Chevy isn’t significantly more spacious than the others either. Sure, it has the widest shoulder room, but in terms of knee and head room it trails the Ritz and only manages to beat the i10 by a slim margin. To its credit, it has good visibility allround which makes it an easy car to pilot in the city. The large glass area and thin pillars which make this possible, can in the meantime, be attributed to it being an old design.

    The i10 manages the same by being a more modern design. Its edges are easy to decipher, the seating high and the A-pillars not too intrusive. It makes for a great city runabout, especially through evening street markets.

    Maruti Suzuki Ritz Interior

    The funkiest interiors of the lot and the large white faced speedo in particular looks very nice. There are lot of intelligent stowage areas inside too

    Maruti Suzuki Ritz Exterior

    Ritz's rear has the most stand out design of the lot. And it's palatable too

    The Ritz though loses favour on this account. The A-pillars can be a problem at intersections and it also takes longer than usual to figure out its ends. And even then, one isn’t completely sure. The rearvisibility meanwhile would have been great, if it weren’t for the hugely wide C-pillars. The Suzuki doesn’t have the friendliest boot either. It’s deep at the bottom, but thanks to the rear seat inclination, there’s verylittle usable space left towards the top.

    Straight from the heart.The highlight of the Ritz is its engine. The 1.2-litre, all aluminium unit, is essentially the same as the A-star’s, albeit with an additional cylinder and minor changes to the bore and stroke dimensions. But, start up the car, get moving and the difference between the Ritz and its smaller sibling is immense. The latter sounds and feels gruff pretty early in the rev range, but the 1.2 unit loves to berevved, just like a Japanese engine should, and vibrations only trickle in at the very top of the rev range. It’salso decently peppy and pretty fuel efficient too. It is certainly our pick of the lot here.

    We quite like the kappa engine on the i10 too. Like the Suzuki, it is a new generation unit and a free revving one at that. And even though it’s less powerful than the Japanese engine, thanks to its gearing and of course, the i10's better power-to-weight ratio compared to the Ritz, it helps the Hyundai post quicker accelerationtimes. It also has the best shifting gearbox in this bunch - short throw, precise and not half asnotchy as the others. It isn’t as efficient as the Suzuki though. The U-VA’s engine meanwhile is the least refined and it also sounds stressed at the top. It’s also the slowest of the lot. To the Chevy’s credit, it does post decent roll on times. It’s slowerin third, but leaves the other two trailing significantly in the top gear slog.

    Engine & Gearbox

    Chevrolet U-VA Engine

    Chevrolet Aveo U-VA Chevy's 1.2-litre engine not as refined or eager as the other two.

    Hyundai i10 Engine

    Hyundai i10 The 1.2 kappa is refined and lends good acceleration to the i10

    Maruti Suzuki Ritz Engine

    Maruti Suzuki Ritz Lovely engine; the 1.2 unit is peppy, refined and decently efficient too

    Dimension

    Chevrolet U-VA (mm)

    Chevrolet U-VA Overall Dimension

    U-VA's lower seats might make getting in and out of the car a little difficult for older eople in comparison. But, for seating three at the rear, the Chevy is best.

    Chevrolet U-VA Boot Dimension

    Boot space is the best of the lot here.

    Hyundai i10 (mm)

    Hyundai i10 Overall Dimension

    i10 is nearly as easy to get in and out of as the Suzuki, but there's less head and knee room to be had. It does have comfy and supportive seats all round though.

    Hyundai i10 Boot Dimension

    Boot space is more usable than on the Ritz.

    Maruti Suzuki Ritz (mm)

    Maruti Suzuki Ritz Overall Dimension

    Ritz thanks to its tall boy design has the most headroom on offer. It also feels the most pacious. Ingress/egress again is as good as it gets in this segment.

    Maruti Suzuki Ritz Boot Dimension

    Bootspace not good with seats up.

    Scorecard & Verdict

    Scorecard

    Body: The Ritz and the U-VA score more for front space on account of having more shoulder room up front. As for the rear, the Maruti and the i10 have more head room but the Chevy offers more shoulder room. Therefore, all cars score exactly the same points for rear room. Overall too, the difference isn't much.

    Drive: The i10 is the quickest car in this test, with the Ritz coming in a close second. Driveability wise, the Ritz returns better figures than the other two, but again it is closely matched. The i10 has the best gearbox here and the Chevy the worst. But, Maruti's way better fuel efficiency really did take us by surprise.

    Comfort: The Ritz rides with authority. It absorbs bumps and undulations with aplomb. It is best riding small car here. The i10 comes in next. The Ritz is also the quietest and the best handling car here; even though the difference in the latter isn't very huge.

    Dynamics: The Chevy has the best steering while the Ritz, the worst. The Maruti's steering feels too artificial compared to the others. U-VA also feels the most planted at high speeds. The i10 scores for being easy to drive and one with the best brakes

    Cost: Four points separate the i10 and the Ritz, but it's enough to crown the latter, the benchmark among small cars. The U-VA is the meantime is a distant third, but if you do choose to buy it, you will at least get the best warranty if nothing else.

    Verdict

    The U-VA is an old car and it’s no surprise that it walks away with the wooden spoon. The Hyundai has finally met its match in the Ritz. The i10 finds itself playing catch up in a number of areas; the Suzuki is more fuel efficient, spacious, comfortable and better equipped. It also has a better engine and presence. The only area where the i10 scores is performance, and, of course, it has the best gearbox. But, overall, it loses its status as the benchmark small car for India. That honour now solely belongs to the Ritz.

    Featured Cars

    • Popular
    • JUST LAUNCHED
    • Upcoming
    Maruti Suzuki Dzire
    Maruti Dzire
    Rs. 8.01 Lakhonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai
    Check On-Road Price
    JUST LAUNCHED
    11th NOV
    Skoda Kylaq
    Skoda Kylaq
    Rs. 9.21 Lakhonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai
    Check On-Road Price
    JUST LAUNCHED
    6th NOV
    Tata Curvv
    Tata Curvv
    Rs. 11.71 Lakhonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai
    Check On-Road Price
    Mahindra XUV 3XO
    Mahindra XUV 3XO
    Rs. 9.15 Lakhonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai
    Check On-Road Price
    Mahindra Thar Roxx
    Mahindra Thar Roxx
    Rs. 15.61 Lakhonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai
    Check On-Road Price
    Hyundai Creta
    Hyundai Creta
    Rs. 13.05 Lakhonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai
    Check On-Road Price
    Tata Nexon
    Tata Nexon
    Rs. 9.39 Lakhonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai
    Check On-Road Price
    Maruti Suzuki Fronx
    Maruti Fronx
    Rs. 8.71 Lakhonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai
    Check On-Road Price
    BMW M5
    BMW M5
    Rs. 2.36 Croreonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai
    Check On-Road Price
    JUST LAUNCHED
    21st NOV
    Mercedes-Benz AMG C 63 S E Performance
    Mercedes-Benz AMG C 63 S E Performance
    Rs. 2.31 Croreonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai
    Check On-Road Price
    JUST LAUNCHED
    12th NOV
    Maruti Suzuki Dzire
    Maruti Dzire
    Rs. 8.01 Lakhonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai
    Check On-Road Price
    JUST LAUNCHED
    11th NOV
    Skoda Kylaq
    Skoda Kylaq
    Rs. 9.21 Lakhonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai
    Check On-Road Price
    JUST LAUNCHED
    6th NOV
    Mercedes-Benz AMG G-Class
    Mercedes-Benz AMG G-Class
    Rs. 4.26 Croreonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai
    Check On-Road Price
    Mercedes-Benz E-Class
    Mercedes-Benz E-Class
    Rs. 93.23 Lakhonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai
    Check On-Road Price
    Volvo EX40
    Volvo EX40
    Rs. 59.31 Lakhonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai
    Check On-Road Price
    BYD eMax 7
    BYD eMax 7
    Rs. 28.40 Lakhonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai
    Check On-Road Price
    Audi Q7 facelift
    LAUNCHING SOON
    Nov 2024
    Audi Q7 facelift

    Rs. 89.00 - 98.00 LakhEstimated Price

    28th Nov 2024Expected Launch

    Get Launch Alert on WhatsApp

    Mahindra BE 6e
    Mahindra BE 6e

    Rs. 17.00 - 21.00 LakhEstimated Price

    26th Nov 2024Unveil Date

    Get Launch Alert on WhatsApp

    Mahindra XEV 9e
    Mahindra XEV 9e

    Rs. 50.00 - 52.00 LakhEstimated Price

    26th Nov 2024Expected Launch

    Get Launch Alert on WhatsApp

    Honda Amaze 2024
    LAUNCHING SOON
    Dec 2024
    Honda Amaze 2024

    Rs. 7.50 - 10.00 LakhEstimated Price

    4th Dec 2024Expected Launch

    Get Launch Alert on WhatsApp

    Toyota Camry 2024
    Toyota Camry 2024

    Rs. 45.00 - 55.00 LakhEstimated Price

    11th Dec 2024Expected Launch

    Get Launch Alert on WhatsApp

    Mahindra XUV.e8
    Mahindra XUV.e8

    Rs. 21.00 - 30.00 LakhEstimated Price

    Dec 2024 (Tentative)Expected Launch

    Get Launch Alert on WhatsApp

    BMW New X3
    BMW New X3

    Rs. 65.00 - 70.00 LakhEstimated Price

    Jan 2025 (Tentative)Expected Launch

    Get Launch Alert on WhatsApp

    Hyundai Creta EV
    Hyundai Creta EV

    Rs. 22.00 - 26.00 LakhEstimated Price

    Jan 2025 (Tentative)Expected Launch

    Get Launch Alert on WhatsApp

    AD
    • maruti suzuki-cars
    • other brands
    Maruti Suzuki Dzire
    Maruti Dzire
    Rs. 8.01 Lakhonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai
    JUST LAUNCHED
    11th NOV
    Maruti Suzuki Fronx
    Maruti Fronx
    Rs. 8.71 Lakhonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai
    Maruti Suzuki Grand Vitara
    Maruti Grand Vitara
    Rs. 12.91 Lakhonwards
    On-Road Price, Navi Mumbai