Toyota Vellfire vs Kia Carnival vs Porsche Macan

CarWale brings you comparison of Toyota Vellfire, Kia Carnival and Porsche Macan. The Toyota Vellfire price is Rs. 1.22 Crore, Kia Carnival price is Rs. 63.90 Lakh and Porsche Macan price is Rs. 96.05 Lakh. The Toyota Vellfire is available in 2487 cc engine with 1 fuel type options: Hybrid (Electric + Petrol), Kia Carnival is available in 2151 cc engine with 1 fuel type options: Diesel and Porsche Macan is available in 1984 cc engine with 1 fuel type options: Petrol. Vellfire provides the mileage of 19.28 kmpl and Carnival provides the mileage of 14.85 kmpl.

Vellfire vs Carnival vs Macan Comparison Overview

Key Highlights	Vellfire	Carnival	Macan
Price	Rs. 1.22 Crore	Rs. 63.90 Lakh	Rs. 96.05 Lakh
Engine Capacity	2487 cc	2151 cc	1984 cc
Power	142 bhp	190 bhp	241 bhp
Transmission	Automatic (e-CVT)	Automatic (TC)	Automatic (DCT)
Fuel Type	Hybrid (Electric + Petrol)	Diesel	Petrol

Hide common featuresHighlight differences

Toyota Vellfire

Rs. 1.22 Crore

Avg. Ex-Showroom price

Kia Carnival

Limousine Plus

Rs. 63.90 Lakh

Avg. Ex-Showroom price

Porsche Macan

Base

Rs. 96.05 Lakh

Avg. Ex-Showroom price

Select Car

Hide common featuresHighlight differences

Toyota Vellfire

Kia Carnival

Limousine Plus

Porsche Macan

Base

Select Car

SPECIFICATIONS
FEATURES
BROCHURE
COLOURS
USER REVIEWS

SPECIFICATIONS
FEATURES
BROCHURE
COLOURS
USER REVIEWS

Specifications and Finance

Finance

Engine & Transmission

Top Speed (kmph)			232
Acceleration (0-100 kmph) (seconds)			6.4
Engine	2487 cc, 4 Cylinders In V Shape, 4 Valves/Cylinder, DOHC	2151 cc, 4 Cylinders Inline, 4 Valves/Cylinder, DOHC	1984 cc, 4 Cylinders Inline, 4 Valves/Cylinder, DOHC
Engine Type		2.2L CRDi	2.0L R4 Turbocharged I4
Fuel Type	Hybrid (Electric + Petrol)	Diesel	Petrol
Max Power (bhp@rpm)	142 bhp @ 6000 rpm	190 bhp @ 3800 rpm	241 bhp @ 5000 rpm
Max Torque (Nm@rpm)	240 Nm @ 4300 rpm	441 Nm @ 1750 rpm	370 Nm @ 1600 rpm
Max Motor Performance	141 bhp @ 4500 rpm
Mileage (ARAI) (kmpl)	19.28View Mileage Details	14.85View Mileage Details
Driving Range (km)	1157	1069
Drivetrain	4WD / AWD	FWD	AWD
Transmission	Automatic (EV/Hybrid) - CVT Gears	Automatic (TC) - 8 Gears, Paddle Shift	Automatic (DCT) - 7 Gears, Manual Override & Paddle Shift, Sport Mode
Emission Standard	BS6 Phase 2	BS6 Phase 2	BS6 Phase 2
Turbocharger / Supercharger		Turbocharged	Turbocharged
Battery	Nickel Metal Hydride,Battery Placed Under Floor Pan
Electric Motor	2 Permanent magnet synchronous Placed At One motor each on front and rear axle
Others	Idle Start/Stop	Idle Start/Stop
Valve/Cylinder (Configuration)	4, DOHC	4, DOHC	4, DOHC

Dimensions & Weight
Capacity

Suspensions, Brakes, Steering & Tyres

Front Suspension	MCPherson Strut	Macpherson Strut with coil spring	Fully Independent Double Wishbone
Rear Suspension	Double Wishbone	Multi Link	Self-tracking Trapezoidal-link
Front Brake Type	Disc	Disc	Ventilated Disc
Rear Brake Type	Disc	Disc	Ventilated Disc
Minimum Turning Radius (metres)	5.9	5.8	5.9
Steering Type	Power assisted (Electric)	Power assisted (Electric)	Power assisted (Electric)
Wheels	Alloy Wheels	Alloy Wheels	Alloy Wheels
Spare Wheel	Alloy	Space Saver	Space Saver
Front Tyres	225 / 55 R19	235 / 60 R18	235 / 55 R19
Rear Tyres	225 / 55 R19	235 / 60 R18	255 / 50 R19

Features

Exterior

Braking & Traction

Anti-Lock Braking System (ABS)
Electronic Brake-force Distribution (EBD)
Brake Assist (BA)
Electronic Stability Program (ESP)
Four-Wheel-Drive	Torque-On-Demand	Torque-On-Demand
Hill Hold Control
Traction Control System (TC/TCS)
Hill Descent Control
Limited Slip Differential (LSD)
Differential Lock		Electronic

Safety

Overspeed Warning	1 beep over 80kmph, Continuous beeps over 120kmph	1 beep over 80kmph, Continuous beeps over 120kmph	1 beep over 80kmph, Continuous beeps over 120kmph
Lane Departure Warning
Emergency Brake Light Flashing
Forward Collision Warning (FCW)
Automatic Emergency Braking (AEB)
High-beam Assist
NCAP Rating	Not Tested	Not Tested	5 Star (Euro NCAP)
Blind Spot Detection
Lane Departure Prevention
Rear Cross-traffic Assist
Airbags	6 Airbags (Driver, Front Passenger, 2 Curtain, Driver Side, Front Passenger Side)	8 Airbags (Driver, Front Passenger, 2 Curtain, Driver Knee, Driver Side, Front Passenger Side, Rear Passenger Side)	8 Airbags (Driver, Front Passenger, 2 Curtain, Driver Side, Front Passenger Side, 2 Rear Passenger Side)
Rear Middle Three Point seatbelt
Rear Middle Head Rest
Tyre Pressure Monitoring System (TPMS)
Child Seat Anchor Points
Seat Belt Warning

Comfort & Convenience

Air Purifier
Umbrella Storage in Door
Electronic Parking Brake	Auto Hold
Air Conditioner	Yes (Automatic Three Zone)	Yes (Automatic Three Zone)	Yes (Automatic Three Zone)
Front AC	Two Zones, Individual Fan Speed Controls	Two Zones, Individual Fan Speed Controls	Two Zones, Individual Fan Speed Controls
Rear AC	Separate Zone, Vents on Roof , Individual Fan Speed Controls	Separate Zone, Vents on Roof	Separate Zone, Vents Behind Front Armrest, Common Fan Speed Control
Third Row AC Zone	Vents on Roof	Blower, Vents on Roof , Common Fan Speed Controls
Heater
Vanity Mirrors on Sun Visors	Driver & Co-Driver	Driver & Co-Driver	Driver & Co-Driver
Cabin Boot Access
Anti-glare Mirrors	Electronic - Internal & Driver Door	Electronic - Internal Only	Electronic - All
Parking Assist	Reverse Camera with Guidance	360 Degree Camera	Reverse Camera with Guidance
Parking Sensors	Front & Rear	Front & Rear	Front & Rear
Cruise Control
Headlight and Ignition On Reminder
Keyless Start/ Button Start
Steering Adjustment	Tilt & Telescopic	Tilt & Telescopic	Tilt & Telescopic
12V Power Outlets			2

Lighting

Ambient Interior Count	14	64
Headlights	LED	LED	LED
Automatic Headlamps
Follow Me Home Headlamps
Cornering Headlights	Active	Active
Taillights	LED	LED	LED
Daytime Running Lights	LED	LED	LED
Fog Lights	LED	LED,LED	LED on front, LED on rear
Ambient Interior Lighting		Multi-colour
Puddle Lamps
Cabin Lamps	Front and Rear	Front and Rear	Front and Rear
Light on Vanity Mirrors	Driver & Co-Driver		Driver & Co-Driver
Rear Reading Lamp	Both Sides	Both Sides
Glovebox Lamp
Headlight Height Adjuster

Locks & Security

Doors, Windows, Mirrors & Wipers

ORVM Colour	Body Coloured	Body Coloured	Body Coloured
Scuff Plates	Plastic	Illuminated	Optional
Power Windows	Front & Rear	Front & Rear	Front & Rear
One Touch Down	All	All	All
One Touch Up	All	All	All
Adjustable ORVMs	Electrically Adjustable & Retractable	Electrically Adjustable & Retractable	Electrically Adjustable & Retractable
Turn Indicators on ORVMs
Rear Defogger
Rear Wiper
Exterior Door Handles	Chrome	Body Coloured	Body Coloured
Rain-sensing Wipers
Interior Door Handles	Chrome	Silver	Chrome
Door Pockets	Front & Rear	Front & Rear	Front & Rear
Side Window Blinds	Rear - Manual		Rear - Manual
Bootlid Opener	Internal with Remote	Electric Tailgate Release	Electric Opening and Closing
Rear Windshield Blind	Manual

Entertainment, Information & Communication

Android Auto	Wireless
Apple CarPlay	Wireless
Display	Touch-screen Display	Touch-screen Display	Touch-screen Display
Touchscreen Size (inch)	13.9	12.3
Integrated (in-dash) Music System
Speakers	15	12	6+
Steering-mounted controls
Voice Command
GPS Navigation System
Bluetooth Compatibility	Phone & Audio Streaming	Phone & Audio Streaming	Phone & Audio Streaming
AUX Compatibility
AM/FM Radio
USB Compatibility
Wireless Charger			Optional
iPod Compatibility
Internal Hard Drive
DVD Playback

Mobile App Features

Storage

Seats & Upholstery

Massage Seats			Optional
Driver Seat Adjustment	12 way electrically adjustable (seat: forward / back, backrest tilt: forward / back, seat height: up / down, lumbar: up / down, lumbar: forward / back, seat base angle: up / down) + 2 way manually adjustable (headrest: up / down)	14 way electrically adjustable (seat: forward / back, backrest tilt: forward / back, seat height: up / down, lumbar: up / down, lumbar: forward / back, seat base angle: up / down, extended thigh support: forward / back) + 2 way manually adjustable (headrest: up / down)	8 way electrically adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back, seat height up / down, seat base angle up / down) + 4 way manually adjustable (headrest up / down, headrest forward / back)
Front Passenger Seat Adjustment	10 way electrically adjustable (seat: forward / back, backrest tilt: forward / back, lumbar: up / down, lumbar: forward / back, seat base angle: up / down) + 2 way manually adjustable (headrest: up / down)	6 way electrically adjustable (seat: forward / back, backrest tilt: forward / back, seat height: up / down) + 2 way manually adjustable (headrest: up / down)	10 way manually adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back, headrest up / down, seat height up / down, headrest forward / back)
Rear Row Seat Adjustment	4 way electrically adjustable with 2 memory presets (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back) + 2 way manually adjustable (headrest up / down)	6 way electrically adjustable (backrest tilt: forward / back, seat base angle: up / down, extended thigh support: forward / back) + 4 way manually adjustable (seat: forward / back, headrest: up / down)	2 way manually adjustable (headrest up / down)
Third Row Seat Adjustment	6 way manually adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back, headrest up / down)	2 way manually adjustable (headrest: up / down)
Seat Upholstery	Leather	Leather	Leather
Leather-wrapped Steering Wheel
Leather-wrapped Gear Knob
Driver Armrest
Rear Passenger Seat Type	Captain Seats	Captain Seats	Bench
Third Row Seat Type	Bench	Bench
Ventilated Seats	Front and Middle Row	Front only
Ventilated Seat Type	Heated and cooled	Not Sure
Interiors	Single Tone	Dual Tone	Single Tone
Interior Colours	Beige	Tuscan & Umber	Black, Agate Grey
Rear Armrest	With Cup Holder		With Cup Holder
Folding Rear Seat	Full	Full	Full
Split Rear Seat	50:50 split	50:50 split	40:20:40 split
Split Third Row Seat	50:50 split	60:40 split
Front Seatback Pockets
Headrests	Front & Rear	Front, Second & Third	Front & Rear

Instrumentation

Instantaneous Consumption
Instrument Cluster	Analogue	Digital	Analogue - Digital
Trip Meter	Multi-Function Display	Electronic 2 Trips	Electronic 2 Trips
Average Fuel Consumption
Average Speed
Distance to Empty
Clock	Digital	Digital	Digital
Low Fuel Level Warning
Door Ajar Warning
Adjustable Cluster Brightness
Gear Indicator
Shift Indicator			Dynamic
Heads Up Display (HUD)
Tachometer	Analogue	Digital	Analogue

Manufacturer Warranty

Brochure

Colours

Black	Fusion Black	Black
Precious Metal	Glacier white Pearl	Gentian Blue Metallic
Platinum White Pearl		Volcano Grey Metallic
		Copper Ruby Metallic
		Jet Black Metallic
		Dolomite Silver Metallic
		Papaya Metallic
		White
		Carrara White Metallic

User Reviews

Overall Rating

4.9/5

9 Ratings

2.1/5

27 Ratings

5.0/5

5 Ratings

Rating Parameters	4.8Exterior	3.8Exterior	4.8Exterior
	5.0Comfort	4.0Comfort	5.0Comfort
	4.8Performance	3.3Performance	4.5Performance
	4.1Fuel Economy	3.2Fuel Economy	4.5Fuel Economy
	4.5Value for Money	2.6Value for Money	4.8Value for Money

Most Helpful Review

This car is indirectly promoting Innova hycross

Not going to sell at this price point, very wrong approach to the Indian Market. Indeed this makes customers feel more value for money now. People would pay 25+L and upgrade to Velfire Or Merc Vclass This is going the Jimny way down

Best Decision by Me

I had to think a lot before buying this car as it is not so cheap but it was worth every single rupee after I bought this car every day I went for a round just to show off my car its super duper comfortable its speed its also very good but I think the mileage can do a little bit better but anyways it's very good for its price and I just can’t explain it anymore in words.

More Expert Reviews on Vellfire, Carnival and Macan

Kia Carnival Limousine Plus First Drive Review

By Desirazu Venkat22 Oct 2024

The new-generation Kia Carnival is offered in fully-loaded variant and only with diesel power

2022 Porsche Macan First Drive Review

By Abhishek Nigam18 May 2022

2022 Porsche Macan First Drive Review

Kia KA4 (Carnival) First Look

By Bilal Ahmed Firfiray30 Jan 2023

Let's take a closer look at the all-new Kia Carnival a.k.a KA4

ToyotaVellfire

Rs. 1.22 Crore onwards

Mercedes-BenzGLS

Rs. 1.32 Crore onwards

PorscheMacan

Rs. 96.05 Lakh onwards

PorscheCayenne

Rs. 1.42 Crore onwards

Land RoverDiscovery

Rs. 97.00 Lakh onwards

Vellfire vs Carnival vs Macan Comparison FAQs

Q: Which car is cheaper between Toyota Vellfire, Kia Carnival and Porsche Macan?

Toyota Vellfire price is Rs. 1.22 Crore, Kia Carnival price is Rs. 63.90 Lakh and Porsche Macan price is Rs. 96.05 Lakh. Hence Kia Carnival is the cheapest amongst these cars.

Q: How is the performance of Vellfire compared to Carnival and Macan?

For the Hi variant, 2487 cc Hybrid (Electric + Petrol) engine of Vellfire produces 142 bhp @ 6000 rpm of power and 240 Nm @ 4300 rpm of torque. For the Limousine Plus variant, 2151 cc Diesel engine of Carnival produces 190 bhp @ 3800 rpm of power and 441 Nm @ 1750 rpm of torque. For the Base variant, 1984 cc Petrol engine of Macan produces 241 bhp @ 5000 rpm of power and 370 Nm @ 1600 rpm of torque.

Disclaimer: For the above Comparison of Compare Vellfire, Carnival and Macan, CarWale has taken utmost care in gathering precise and accurate information about price, specs, features, colours etc, however, CarWale cannot be held liable for any direct or indirect damage/loss. For Compare Vellfire, Carnival and Macan comparison, we have considered most popular variant on CarWale as default, however, any variant of these cars can be compared.

Home
Compare Cars
Toyota Vellfire vs Kia Carnival vs Porsche Macan

Length (mm)	5010	5155	4726
Width (mm)	1850	1995	1922
Height (mm)	1950	1775	1621
Wheelbase (mm)	3000	3090	2807
Kerb Weight (kg)	2065		1845

Doors (Doors)	5	5	5
Seating Capacity (Person)	7	7	5
No of Rows (Rows)	3	3	2
Bootspace (litres)			458
Fuel Tank Capacity (litres)	60	72	65

Sunroof / Moonroof	Electrically Adjustable	Electrically Adjustable	Optional
Roof-mounted Antenna
Body-coloured Bumpers
Chrome Finish Exhaust Pipe

Engine Immobiliser
Central Locking	Remote with Boot Opener	Keyless	Remote with Boot Opener
Speed Sensing Door Lock
Child Safety Lock

Find My Car			Optional
Check Vehicle Status via App			Optional
Geo-fence			Optional
Emergency Call			Optional
Over The Air (OTA) Updates
Remote AC: On / Off via App			Optional
Alexa Compatibility

Cup Holders	Front & Rear	Front Only	Front & Rear
Driver Armrest Storage
Cooled Glovebox
Sunglass Holder
Third Row Cup Holders

Battery Warranty (In Years)	8
Battery Warranty (In Kilometres)	160000
Warranty (In Years)	3	3	3
Warranty (In Kilometres)	100000	Unlimited	60000