Tata Punch vs Mahindra-Renault Logan [2009-2011]

CarWale brings you comparison of Tata Punch and Mahindra-Renault Logan [2009-2011]. The Tata Punch price is Rs. 6.13 Lakh and Mahindra-Renault Logan [2009-2011] price is Rs. 4.71 Lakh. The Tata Punch is available in 1199 cc engine with 2 fuel type options: Petrol and CNG and Mahindra-Renault Logan [2009-2011] is available in 1390 cc engine with 1 fuel type options: Petrol. Logan [2009-2011] provides the mileage of 12.1 kmpl.

Punch vs Logan [2009-2011] Comparison Overview

Key Highlights	Punch	Logan [2009-2011]
Price	Rs. 6.13 Lakh	Rs. 4.71 Lakh
Engine Capacity	1199 cc	1390 cc
Power	87 bhp	-
Transmission	Manual	Manual
Fuel Type	Petrol	Petrol

Hide common featuresHighlight differences

Tata Punch

Pure MT

Rs. 6.13 Lakh

Avg. Ex-Showroom price

Mahindra-Renault Logan [2009-2011]

GLE 1.4 BS-IV

Rs. 4.71 Lakh

Last Recorded Price

Quick Compare
Ad

Driving Range (km)		807
Ground Clearance (mm)	187	205
Bootspace (litres)	366	405

Renault KIGER - sporty smart stunning

KNOW MORE

Specifications and Finance

Finance

Engine & Transmission

Engine	1199 cc, 3 Cylinders Inline, 4 Valves/Cylinder, SOHC	1390 cc, 4 Cylinders Inline, 2 Valves/Cylinder	999 cc, 3 Cylinders Inline, 4 Valves/Cylinder, DOHC
Engine Type	1.2 Revotron	1.4L Petrol	1.0L Energy
Fuel Type	Petrol	Petrol	Petrol
Max Power (bhp@rpm)	87 bhp @ 6000 rpm	75@5500	71 bhp @ 6250 rpm
Max Torque (Nm@rpm)	115 Nm @ 3250 rpm	110@3000	96 Nm @ 3500 rpm
Mileage (ARAI) (kmpl)		12.1View Mileage Details	20.18View Mileage Details
Driving Range (km)			807
Drivetrain	FWD		FWD
Transmission	Manual - 5 Gears	Manual - 5 Gears	Manual - 5 Gears
Emission Standard	BS6 Phase 2		BS6 Phase 2
Others	Idle Start/Stop
Valve/Cylinder (Configuration)	4, SOHC	2	4, DOHC

Dimensions & Weight
Capacity

Suspensions, Brakes, Steering & Tyres

Front Suspension	Independent, Lower Wishbone Mcpherson Strut with Coil Spring	MacPherson strut	McPherson Strut with Lower Triangle & Coil Spring, Anti-roll Bar & Traverse Arm
Rear Suspension	Semi-independent Twist Beam with Coil Spring and Shock Absorber	Non-independant, H-type beam	Torsion Beam Axle
Front Brake Type	Disc	Disc	Disc
Rear Brake Type	Drum	Drum	Drum
Minimum Turning Radius (metres)		5.3
Steering Type	Power assisted (Electric)		Power assisted (Electric)
Wheels	Steel Rims		Steel Rims
Spare Wheel	Steel		Steel
Front Tyres	185 / 70 R15	185 / 70 R14	195 / 60 R16
Rear Tyres	185 / 70 R15	185 / 70 R14	195 / 60 R16

Features

Exterior

Braking & Traction

Safety

Overspeed Warning	1 beep over 80kmph, Continuous beeps over 120kmph	1 beep over 80kmph, Continuous beeps over 120kmph
Puncture Repair Kit
NCAP Rating	5 Star (Global NCAP)	4 Star (Global NCAP)
Airbags	2 Airbags (Driver, Front Passenger)	2 Airbags (Driver, Front Passenger)
Tyre Pressure Monitoring System (TPMS)
Child Seat Anchor Points
Seat Belt Warning

Comfort & Convenience

Lighting
Locks & Security

Doors, Windows, Mirrors & Wipers

Entertainment, Information & Communication
Storage

Seats & Upholstery

Driver Seat Adjustment	6 way manually adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back, headrest up / down)		6 way manually adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back, headrest up / down)
Front Passenger Seat Adjustment	6 way manually adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back, headrest up / down)		6 way manually adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back, headrest up / down)
Seat Upholstery	Fabric	Fabric	Fabric
Driver Armrest
Rear Passenger Seat Type	Bench		Bench
Interiors	Dual Tone		Single Tone
Interior Colours	Black / White		Black
Folding Rear Seat	Full		Full
Headrests	Front & Rear		Front & Rear

Instrumentation

Manufacturer Warranty

Brochure

Colours

Daytona Grey	Fiery Black	Stealth Black
Orcus White	Java Brown	Moonlight Silver
	Toreador Red	Ice Cool White
	Mist Silver
	Sahara Beige
	Diamond White

User Reviews

Overall Rating

5.0/5

7 Ratings

4.3/5

20 Ratings

Rating Parameters	5.0Exterior	4.3Exterior
	5.0Comfort	4.2Comfort
	4.7Performance	4.3Performance
	5.0Fuel Economy	4.0Fuel Economy
	5.0Value for Money	4.3Value for Money

Most Helpful Review

Tata Punch Pure MT

Best 5 star car for city driving.Good interior space.Rear Power window is not available in base model.Fuel economy is 18 kmpl in city and 14 kmpl in bumper to bumper traffic.Good safety rating.Good service center network.

Excellent service from renault madurai ringroad

Excellent service from Madurai ring road showroom. Happy to purchase a Renault my Dream car. Showroom ambience really nice.

More Expert Reviews on Punch and Logan [2009-2011]

Tata Punch i-CNG First Look

By Ninad Ambre25 Feb 2023

The Tata Punch is currently one of the best-selling models from the carmaker's portfolio. We believe a CNG-powered version would make its case stronger and guess what? It is coming soon. It will share its engine option with the Altroz. Likewise, it will be made available with a similar twin-cylinder kit in the boot. Our first impressions of the premium hatchback are out here, and we shall now delve into the details of the new Punch i-CNG. Before we begin, let us bring to your notice that the one displayed at the 2023 Auto Expo looked identical to the standard Punch. The only difference between the two in terms of looks was the ‘i-CNG’ badge on the boot.

Word Play

Think Renault, think of the turbo era in Formula 1. Renault was the pioneer of the turbo era in Formula 1 which began in 1977 and lastes till 1988 with 1.5-litre engines

Tata Punch vs Renault Kiger

By Sagar Bhanushali12 Apr 2022

Here we have the top-of-the-range Tata Punch Creative versus the Renault Kiger RXZ, two standout urban vehicles which blur the line between a city car and a compact SUV. Here's how both fared in our comparison test.

Length (mm)	3827	4247	3991
Width (mm)	1742	1740	1750
Height (mm)	1615	1534	1605
Wheelbase (mm)	2445	2630	2500
Ground Clearance (mm)	187		205

Doors (Doors)	5	4	5
Seating Capacity (Person)	5	5	5
No of Rows (Rows)	2		2
Bootspace (litres)	366		405
Fuel Tank Capacity (litres)	37	50	40

Roof-mounted Antenna
Body-coloured Bumpers
Body Kit	Cladding - Black/Grey	Black
Rub-strips		Black

Anti-Lock Braking System (ABS)
Electronic Brake-force Distribution (EBD)
Electronic Stability Program (ESP)
Hill Hold Control
Traction Control System (TC/TCS)

Air Purifier
Air Conditioner	Yes (Manual)	Yes (Manual)	Yes (Manual)
Front AC	Single Zone, Common Fan Speed Control		Single Zone, Common Fan Speed Control
Heater
Cabin Boot Access
Headlight and Ignition On Reminder
Steering Adjustment	Tilt
12V Power Outlets			2

Headlights	Halogen	Halogen
Taillights	Halogen	LED
Daytime Running Lights		LED
Cabin Lamps	Front	Front
Light on Vanity Mirrors	Driver & Co-Driver
Headlight Height Adjuster

Engine Immobiliser
Central Locking	With Key	With Key
Speed Sensing Door Lock
Child Safety Lock

ORVM Colour	Black	Black
Power Windows	Front Only	Front Only
Adjustable ORVMs	Internally Adjustable	Internally Adjustable
Turn Indicators on ORVMs
Exterior Door Handles	Black	Black
Interior Door Handles	Black	Unpainted
Door Pockets	Front & Rear	Front & Rear
Bootlid Opener	Electric Tailgate Release	Internal

Instantaneous Consumption
Instrument Cluster	Digital	Digital
Trip Meter	Electronic 2 Trips	Electronic 2 Trips
Average Fuel Consumption
Average Speed
Distance to Empty
Clock	Digital	Digital
Low Fuel Level Warning
Door Ajar Warning
Adjustable Cluster Brightness
Gear Indicator
Tachometer	Analogue	Digital

Battery Warranty (In Kilometres)	Not Applicable	Not Applicable
Warranty (In Years)	3	2
Warranty (In Kilometres)	100000	50000