Tata Harrier vs BMW X1 [2010-2012]

CarWale brings you comparison of Tata Harrier and BMW X1 [2010-2012]. The Tata Harrier price is Rs. 14.99 Lakh and BMW X1 [2010-2012] price is Rs. 24.30 Lakh. The Tata Harrier is available in 1956 cc engine with 1 fuel type options: Diesel and BMW X1 [2010-2012] is available in 1995 cc engine with 2 fuel type options: Petrol and Diesel. Harrier provides the mileage of 16.8 kmpl and X1 [2010-2012] provides the mileage of 11.25 kmpl.

Harrier vs X1 [2010-2012] Comparison Overview

Key Highlights	Harrier	X1 [2010-2012]
Price	Rs. 14.99 Lakh	Rs. 24.30 Lakh
Engine Capacity	1956 cc	1995 cc
Power	168 bhp	150 bhp
Transmission	Manual	Automatic
Fuel Type	Diesel	Petrol

Hide common featuresHighlight differences

Tata Harrier

Smart

Rs. 14.99 Lakh

Avg. Ex-Showroom price

BMW X1 [2010-2012]

sDrive18i

Rs. 24.30 Lakh

Last Recorded Price

Specifications and Finance

Finance

Engine & Transmission

Acceleration (0-100 kmph) (seconds)			11.98
Engine	1956 cc, 4 Cylinders Inline, 4 Valves/Cylinder, DOHC	1995 cc, 4 Cylinders Inline, 4 Valves/Cylinder	1956 cc, 4 Cylinders Inline, 4 Valves/Cylinder, DOHC
Engine Type	Kryotec 2.0L Turbocharged Engine	straight 4 petrol engine	2.0 Multijet II
Fuel Type	Diesel	Petrol	Diesel
Max Power (bhp@rpm)	168 bhp @ 3750 rpm	150 bhp @	172 bhp @ 3750 rpm
Max Torque (Nm@rpm)	350 Nm @ 1750-2500 rpm	200 Nm @ 3600 rpm	350 Nm @ 1750-2500 rpm
Mileage (ARAI) (kmpl)	16.8View Mileage Details	11.25View Mileage Details
Driving Range (km)	840
Drivetrain	FWD	RWD	FWD
Transmission	Manual - 6 Gears, Sport Mode	Automatic - 6 Gears	Manual - 6 Gears
Emission Standard	BS6 Phase 2		BS6 Phase 2
Turbocharger / Supercharger	Turbocharged		Turbocharged
Electric Motor
Others			Idle Start/Stop
Valve/Cylinder (Configuration)	4, DOHC	4	4, DOHC

Dimensions & Weight
Capacity

Suspensions, Brakes, Steering & Tyres

Front Suspension	Independent,Lower Wishbone,McPherson Strut with coil spring & Anti Roll Bar	Double joint strut front axle	McPherson Strut with Lower Control Arm
Rear Suspension	Semi Independent Twist Blade with Panhard Rod & Coil Spring	multi-arm rear axle	Multi Link Suspension with Strut Assembly
Front Brake Type	Disc	Disc	Disc
Rear Brake Type	Drum	Disc	Disc
Minimum Turning Radius (metres)			5.7
Steering Type	Power assisted (Electric)		Power assisted (Hydraulic)
Wheels	Alloy Wheels		Alloy Wheels
Spare Wheel		Alloy	Space Saver
Front Tyres	235 / 65 R17	225 / 50 R17	225 / 60 R17
Rear Tyres	235 / 65 R17	225 / 50 R17	225 / 60 R17

Features

Exterior

Braking & Traction

Safety

Overspeed Warning	1 beep over 80kmph, Continuous beeps over 120kmph	1 beep over 80kmph, Continuous beeps over 120kmph
Emergency Brake Light Flashing
Puncture Repair Kit
NCAP Rating	5 Star (Bharat NCAP)	Not Tested
Airbags	6 Airbags (Driver, Front Passenger, 2 Curtain, Driver Side, Front Passenger Side)	2 Airbags (Driver, Passenger)
Rear Middle Three Point seatbelt
Tyre Pressure Monitoring System (TPMS)
Child Seat Anchor Points
Seat Belt Warning

Comfort & Convenience

Electronic Parking Brake
Air Conditioner	Yes (Automatic Climate Control)	Yes (Automatic Climate Control)	Yes (Manual)
Front AC	Single Zone, Common Fan Speed Control		Single Zone, Common Fan Speed Control
Rear AC	Blower, Vents on Pillars		Blower, Vents Behind Front Armrest
Third Row AC Zone
Heater
Vanity Mirrors on Sun Visors			Driver & Co-Driver
Cabin Boot Access
Anti-glare Mirrors	Manual - Internal Only		Manual - Internal Only
Parking Assist			Reverse Camera
Headlight and Ignition On Reminder
Keyless Start/ Button Start
Steering Adjustment	Tilt & Telescopic	Tilt & Telescopic	Tilt & Telescopic
12V Power Outlets	2	3

Lighting

Locks & Security

Doors, Windows, Mirrors & Wipers

ORVM Colour	Black		Black
Scuff Plates
Power Windows	Front & Rear	Front & Rear	Front & Rear
One Touch Down			Front
One Touch Up			Front
Adjustable ORVMs	Externally Adjustable	Electrically Adjustable & Retractable	Electrically Adjustable
Turn Indicators on ORVMs
Rear Defogger
Rear Wiper
Exterior Door Handles	Black		Body Coloured
Interior Door Handles	Chrome		Painted
Door Pockets	Front & Rear	Front & Rear	Front & Rear
Bootlid Opener	Internal with Remote	Internal with Remote	Electric Tailgate Release

Entertainment, Information & Communication

Storage

Seats & Upholstery

Driver Seat Adjustment	6 way manually adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back, headrest up / down)		8 way manually adjustable (seat: forward / back, backrest tilt: forward / back, headrest: up / down, seat height: up / down)
Front Passenger Seat Adjustment	6 way manually adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back, headrest up / down)		6 way manually adjustable (seat: forward / back, backrest tilt: forward / back, headrest: up / down)
Rear Row Seat Adjustment	2 way manually adjustable (headrest: up / down)		2 way manually adjustable (headrest up / down)
Seat Upholstery	Fabric	Fabric	Fabric
Leather-wrapped Steering Wheel
Leather-wrapped Gear Knob
Driver Armrest
Rear Passenger Seat Type	Bench		Bench
Interiors	Dual Tone		Dual Tone
Interior Colours			Black and Grey
Rear Armrest			With Cup Holder
Folding Rear Seat	Full		Full
Split Rear Seat	60:40 split		60:40 split
Front Seatback Pockets
Headrests	Front & Rear	Front & Rear	Front & Rear

Instrumentation

Instantaneous Consumption
Instrument Cluster	Digital		Digital
Trip Meter	Electronic 2 Trips		Electronic 2 Trips
Average Fuel Consumption
Average Speed
Distance to Empty
Clock	Digital	Digital	Digital
Low Fuel Level Warning
Door Ajar Warning
Adjustable Cluster Brightness
Gear Indicator
Shift Indicator
Tachometer	Digital		Analogue

Manufacturer Warranty

Brochure

Colours

	Ash Grey		Brilliant Black
	Lunar White		Techno Metallic Green
			Galaxy Blue
			Grigio Magnesio Grey
			Exotica Red
			Silvery Moon
			Pearl White

User Reviews

Overall Rating

4.6/5

55 Ratings

3.0/5

1 Rating

4.2/5

28 Ratings

Rating Parameters	4.8Exterior	4.8Exterior
	4.7Comfort	4.7Comfort
	4.7Performance	4.7Performance
	4.4Fuel Economy	4.3Fuel Economy
	4.6Value for Money	4.3Value for Money

Most Helpful Review

Do or Die

I liked the budget of the car, looks, mileage and servicing and maintenance, also the interior and speed of the car, when I went for bye they were taking care of me and carefully they delivered my car.

Wonderful experience

A great driving experience I had with the Jeep Compass. Either off-road or smooth road, you will feel great comfort next to luxury. Smooth drive even on rough stretches. Loaded with a variety of features.

More Expert Reviews on Harrier and X1 [2010-2012]

2023 Tata Harrier Facelift First Drive Review

By Jay Shah14 Oct 2023

We have finally driven the new Tata Harrier to tell you about our driving impressions.

Boom Boom Bimmer

December 2010 was a great month for BMW as it unveiled a product that was its cheapest yet, the X1. But, the trust in BMW ensured buyers did not look down upon it; instead they jumped at it. The result was massive bookings and a long wait of several months to drive one out of the showrooms. Sceptics however, say it’s common for any new car to witness such response; first few months are after all called the honeymoon period for a new car for a reason. The question then is, is the X1 as good as one expects a BMW to be? Is it fun to drive? And do its booming sales, actually make it worth owning? To find out, we drove the baby BMW, the X1.

Length (mm)	4605	4454	4405
Width (mm)	1922	2044	1818
Height (mm)	1718	1545	1640
Wheelbase (mm)	2741	2760	2636
Kerb Weight (kg)		1505

Doors (Doors)	5	5	5
Seating Capacity (Person)	5	5	5
No of Rows (Rows)	2	2	2
Bootspace (litres)	445	420
Fuel Tank Capacity (litres)	50	63	60

Roof-mounted Antenna
Body-coloured Bumpers
Body Kit			Cladding - Black/Grey

Anti-Lock Braking System (ABS)
Electronic Brake-force Distribution (EBD)
Brake Assist (BA)
Electronic Stability Program (ESP)
Hill Hold Control
Traction Control System (TC/TCS)

Headlights	LED Projector	Projector with Xenon	LED
Taillights	LED		Halogen
Daytime Running Lights	LED		LED
Cabin Lamps	Front and Rear		Front and Rear
Light on Vanity Mirrors			Co-Driver Only
Rear Reading Lamp
Headlight Height Adjuster

Engine Immobiliser
Central Locking	Remote	Remote
Speed Sensing Door Lock
Child Safety Lock

Android Auto		Wireless
Apple CarPlay		Wireless
Display		Touch-screen Display
Touchscreen Size (inch)		8.4
Integrated (in-dash) Music System
Speakers	6	4
Steering-mounted controls
Bluetooth Compatibility		Phone & Audio Streaming
AUX Compatibility
AM/FM Radio
USB Compatibility
iPod Compatibility

Cup Holders	Front Only	Rear Only	Front & Rear
Driver Armrest Storage
Sunglass Holder

Battery Warranty (In Kilometres)	No Applicable		Not Applicable
Warranty (In Years)	3	2	3
Warranty (In Kilometres)	100000	Unlimited	100000